It has been nearly three decades since Tom Hanks made his directorial debut with “That Thing You Do!” and the film’s evolution into cult status is a testament not only to its charm but also to the changing landscape of cinematic appreciation. Initially, the film, which chronicles the meteoric rise and subsequent fall of a fictional 1960s boy band, received mixed critiques upon its release. However, Hanks has taken a moment to reflect on its reception and the oddity of critical opinion over time. In a candid discussion on the podcast “Conan O’Brien Needs a Friend,” Hanks humorously commented on the unpredictability of critics, illustrating how their evaluations can swiftly swing from praise to disdain.
Hanks has always maintained a sense of humor about the ups and downs that accompany movie-making. When recalling the initial reactions to “That Thing You Do!”, he cleverly remarked on the nature of film criticism, likening it to a thrilling carnival ride rather than a steady path of approval. Critics, in Hanks’ eyes, can often oscillate dramatically in their reviews. His reflections paint a picture of a tumultuous relationship, where a film that seems unappreciated may later resonate profoundly with audiences. He noted that those who once dismissed the film now laud it, attributing its unforeseen success to the passage of time that allows for genuine appreciation.
The Passage of Time and Cultural Resonance
Hanks stresses that the legacy of a film often requires time to mature. In his conversation with O’Brien, he mentioned how past critiques can feel irrelevant as a film settles into its place in cinematic history. “That Thing You Do!” serves as a vivid reminder of this phenomenon; what was once viewed as a misfire has transformed into a celebrated classic. The film’s infectious title track, along with its nostalgic depiction of the music industry, has continued to resonate, leading audiences to reconsider its value and significance in a cultural context.
During the podcast, Hanks shared his own journey with public perception, revealing how some harsh initial critiques still linger years later. Yet, he possesses a profound faith in the resilience of storytelling—something that transcends the arbitrary judgments of critics. He recalled a particularly dismissive review from a critic who later recognized the film’s cult classic status, an irony not lost on Hanks. This experience illustrates not only the unpredictability of creative endeavors but also how societal values shift over time.
Legacy and Impact
The camaraderie between Hanks and his cast—featuring talents like Liv Tyler, Johnathon Schaech, and Charlize Theron—along with the acclaimed title song that received Oscar nominations, enhances the film’s enduring legacy. “That Thing You Do!” is more than just a nostalgic romp; it has morphed into a cultural artifact that provides insights into the ever-changing dynamics of film and music. Hanks’ reflections remind us that the true value of a film may not be immediately clear, but with time and a shift in perspective, it can emerge as a beloved classic that truly captures the spirit of its era.